Get Started

Apple store buttonGoogle play button
Create Account
Sign In / Get Started

From Niche to Core: Transforming Alternative Investments in Pension Strategies

By CARL AI Labs - Deep Research implementation by Gunnar Cuevas (Manager, Fitz Roy)

This research report examines the shift of alternative investments from niche allocations to a central role in defined benefit and contribution plans, analyzing drivers, challenges, and integration strategies in today’s evolving market and regulatory environments.

December 26, 2025 11:52 AM

Get Started

Apple store buttonGoogle play button

Summary: The Evolution of Core – Alternatives’ Strategic Role in Defined Benefit and Contribution Plans

This report synthesizes an extensive body of research on how alternative investments are transitioning from niche components into core portfolio allocations for defined benefit (DB) and defined contribution (DC) pension plans. The detailed analysis examines drivers, challenges, integration strategies, and the impact of evolving regulatory, market, and operational environments. It also outlines actionable insights for plan sponsors, asset managers, and regulatory bodies.

The report is organized into the following sections:

  • Executive Summary
  • Introduction and Background
  • Drivers of the Alternatives Transition
  • Challenges and Risks
  • Integration Strategies and Operational Approaches
  • Regulatory and Macro Environment
  • Comparative Data and Key Benchmarks
  • Actionable Insights
  • Conclusions and Recommendations

Executive Summary

Key themes include:

  • Diversification and Liability Management: DB and DC plans are adopting alternative investments to improve risk-adjusted returns and match long-term liabilities.
  • Operational Transformation: Automation, digital integration, and outsourced chief investment officer (OCIO) models are critical for integrating complex alternative assets.
  • Regulatory Revisions: Recent regulatory shifts—exemplified by the August 7, 2025 Executive Order—and evolving ERISA guidance are catalyzing changes in fiduciary practice and expanding DC plan access to alternative assets.
  • Macro and Market Forces: Market consolidation, technological advances in data management, and dynamic macroeconomic factors are reshaping the investment landscape in both the public and private sectors.

Introduction and Background

Purpose of the Research

This research was initiated to address the need for a critical re-evaluation of long-term capital deployment strategies in pension plans. With traditional 60/40 portfolios increasingly underperforming against funding targets and liability requirements, the integration of alternatives has become vital for:

  • Diversifying portfolios
  • Enhancing yield and return consistency over long time horizons
  • Matching liabilities more precisely to reduce funding volatility

Context and Rationale

The study comes at a time when:

  • Structural shifts such as pension consolidation and market transformations call for advanced asset-based finance models
  • Regulatory pressures and evolving fiduciary duties require innovative, well-documented strategies
  • Both DB and DC plans are encouraged to leverage alternatives via pooled investment vehicles and innovative OCIO models to benefit small- and medium-sized plan sponsors
  • A low-yield environment and increasing market volatility compel pension funds to look beyond traditional asset classes for improved performance

Get Access

Tearing Down Barriers to the Alternative Investment Universe

CARL provides you with a selection of thrilling alternative investment opportunities you might never have heard of before. Build your wealth and diversify your portfolio with alternative investments – anywhere, anytime, with one easy-to-use mobile app.

How CARL works

Drivers of the Alternatives Transition

The move from niche to core allocations is propelled by multiple converging factors:

Market and Economic Drivers

  • Low-Yield Environment: Traditional bonds and equity assets struggle to deliver adequate returns in persistent low-rate conditions.
  • Inflation and Increased Longevity: Rising inflation and longer life expectancies increase pension liabilities, necessitating investments with higher yield potentials.
  • Alpha Generation and Illiquidity Premiums: Alternative assets offer sustainable return premiums (200–500 basis points over public benchmarks), as well as diversification benefits.

Strategic and Operational Drivers

  • Enhanced Diversification: DB plans (e.g., shifting 5–8% allocations into alternatives) have shown improved surplus volatility reductions and funding stability.
  • Liability-Driven Investing (LDI): Using fixed income instruments aligned with pension liabilities—via glide path strategies and derivative overlays—helps mitigate market and interest rate risks.
  • OCIO and Outsourcing Models: The growing enrollment in OCIO partnerships, driven by cost efficiency and scalability, enables effective management of alternative exposures with improved governance and transparency.

Regulatory and Policy Shifts

  • Executive Orders and Legislative Reforms: The August 7, 2025 Executive Order “Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401(k) Investors” and the proposed Retirement Investment Choice Act aim to remove regulatory barriers and clarify fiduciary duties regarding alternative investments.
  • Revised ERISA Guidance: Ongoing updates and rescissions of prior cautionary statements (e.g., the December 21, 2021 Supplemental Private Equity Statement) have created a more flexible regulatory environment for incorporating alternatives.

Challenges and Risks

Despite the compelling benefits, the strategic integration of alternatives comes with several challenges:

Operational and Liquidity Challenges

  • Valuation Complexity: Alternatives like private equity and infrastructure often have infrequent or subjective valuations, complicating performance measurement and risk management.
  • Liquidity Constraints: Illiquid assets require robust liquidity management strategies such as maintaining steady commitment plans, secondary market sales at discounts, and co-investment mechanisms.
  • High Cost Structures: Operational and administrative costs for alternatives can be 5–10× those of public market operations, highlighting the critical importance of scale and automation to reduce per-unit fees.

Regulatory and Fiduciary Challenges

  • Legal and Litigation Risks: Expanding alternatives in DC plans creates potential ERISA litigation risks, especially if fiduciaries do not adhere to robust due diligence and transparent fee structures.
  • Cross-Jurisdictional Regulatory Divergence: Differences between U.S. and European regulatory frameworks (e.g., AIFMD requirements) pose challenges in implementing global alternative strategies.

Manager and Selection Risks

  • Selection Bias and Manager Skill: Observations of alternative asset outperformance may reflect selection bias or superior manager skill rather than the intrinsic benefit of illiquidity premiums.
  • Due Diligence Complexity: Robust risk assessment frameworks and customized benchmarking are required to evaluate alternative asset managers effectively.

Integration Strategies and Operational Approaches

Successful integration of alternative assets into pension portfolios involves a confluence of advanced analytical tools, technological innovation, and strategic asset allocation:

Combined Allocation Approaches

  • Diversified Liability-Hedging vs. Return-Seeking Allocations:
    • DB plans deploy dual strategies: using active management for liability hedging (e.g., fixed income mandates) and passive strategies for return generation.
    • Asset allocation frameworks distinguish between return-seeking roles (core equities, diversifiers such as hedge funds and private equity) and liability-hedging roles (credit-backed diversifiers, fixed income overlays).

Technological and Operational Enhancements

  • Automation and Digital Integration:
    • Cloud-based platforms (e.g., Clearwater Analytics, SimCorp One) and API-driven solutions are being adopted to automate data processing, reduce manual document handling, and provide real-time risk analytics.
    • AI and machine learning applications in risk management, data extraction, and workflow automation have demonstrated up to 80–95% reductions in operational labor requirements.
  • Outsourced Investment Management (OCIO):
    • The shift toward OCIO models supports complex multi-asset strategies, offering tailored investment philosophies, fee transparency, and robust compliance protocols.
    • Governance frameworks clearly delineate the roles between internal investment committees and OCIO providers to ensure fiduciary oversight.

Portfolio Structuring for DC Plans

  • Pooled Investment Vehicles and Managed Accounts:
    • Institutional-quality alternative investment opportunities are being “retailized” through integrated platforms (e.g., CITs, target date funds with private market exposures) designed to overcome liquidity and minimum investment constraints.
  • Customized Glide Path and LDI Strategies:
    • Glide path designs are becoming increasingly dynamic, implementing both de-risking and re-risking phases to manage funded status volatility.
    • LDI strategies integrate fixed income instruments with alternative asset exposures to maintain portfolio durations that match pension liabilities.

Sophisticated Alternative Investments Aren’t Just for Institutions Anymore

Get Started

Regulatory and Macro Environment

The regulatory context remains a pivotal influence on pension investment strategies:

Key Policy Developments

  • Executive Orders and Legislative Action:
    • The August 7, 2025 Executive Order and subsequent legislative proposals (e.g., the Retirement Investment Choice Act) are instrumental in shaping the regulatory landscape, enabling broader inclusion of alternatives in 401(k) plans.
  • Rescissions and Updated Guidance:
    • The Department of Labor’s rescission of prior Biden-era guidance on private equity marks a shift toward a more flexible framework, reducing litigation risks.
  • International Regulatory Impacts:
    • Divergences between U.S. and European fee structures and data transparency requirements necessitate different approaches in global portfolio implementations.

Macro Trends and Economic Conditions

  • Market Consolidation and Capital Allocation Shifts:
    • Growing pension fund consolidation and trends in asset-based financing are spurring more efficient investment strategies.
  • Inflation and Interest Rate Dynamics:
    • Changing discount rates and evolving interest rate environments significantly influence LDI and asset-liability matching models.
  • Technological and Data Advances:
    • Innovations in digital data management platforms and automation tools continue to enhance regulatory compliance and risk management across pension portfolios.

Comparative Data and Key Benchmarks

A summary table highlights several key comparative metrics drawn from the research:

CategoryDefined Benefit (DB) PlansDefined Contribution (DC) PlansNotes / Observations
Alternative Allocation5–8% into private markets for improved funding and volatility reductionEmerging incorporation (currently ~2–3% but trending upward)Institutional insights drive increasing DC exposure through target date funds and CITs
Cost StructuresHigher operational costs (270–280 bps for private equity vs. 34 bps for public equities)Similar challenges: higher fee structures and liquidity concernsScale and automation reduce costs (every extra $1B AUM reduces unit cost by ~5 bps)
Risk-Adjusted ReturnEvidence of incremental yield improvements (e.g., premium uplifts 50bps → 72bps in private placements)Enhanced diversification to close DB–DC return gapsApollo analysis: 25% allocation to privates can boost net annual returns from 6.52% to 7.54%
Governance & OversightDual strategy: active liability-hedging and passive return-seeking with robust LDI frameworksEvolving policies with expanded fiduciary discretion and safe harbor criteriaOCIO and pooled solutions are critical for DC plan modernization
Regulatory / Policy DriversDOL and ERISA fiduciary responsibilities emphasizing due diligence and liquidity managementPending regulatory updates from DOL, SEC, and Treasury based on EO 14330Legislative action (e.g., Retirement Investment Choice Act) in support

Actionable Insights

Based on the research, the following actionable insights are recommended:

  • Enhanced Due Diligence Protocols:
    • Develop rigorous frameworks for evaluating alternative asset managers to counter selection bias and monitor performance.
    • Incorporate advanced risk analytics (e.g., dynamic stress testing and real-time data monitoring) into the due diligence process.
  • Modernize Operational Infrastructure:
    • Invest in cloud-native, API-first platforms that increase automation, reduce manual document handling, and support real-time reporting across both public and private asset classes.
    • Leverage OCIO models to transfer complex investment management functions and streamline back-office operations.
  • Adopt Tailored LDI and Glide Path Strategies:
    • Construct dynamic LDI frameworks that adjust asset allocations according to funded status triggers.
    • Implement customized glide paths that balance de-risking (to lock in funding improvements) and re-risking (to capitalize on market opportunities).
  • Regulatory Engagement and Advocacy:
    • Actively participate in regulatory workshops and engage with policymakers to help shape revised ERISA guidance.
    • Monitor legislative proposals (e.g., the Retirement Investment Choice Act) to prepare for expanded access to alternative investments in DC plans.
  • Cost Optimization and Scale Strategies:
    • Consider pooling assets through platforms or multi-investor vehicles to benefit from economies of scale.
    • Automate middle- and back-office processes to reduce operational costs and improve transparency.

Get Started

3 Easy Steps to Start Investing With CARL

Investing in quants is as easy as pie if you've got CARL on your side. Investors can set up an CARL account quickly and easily.

Set Up Your Account

Quickly and securely create your account, verify your investor status and become a member of our community.

Analyze Investments

Using the tools within the CARL app, determine which strategies at what allocations are right for your investment goals.

Fund Your Investment

Simply save your portfolio settings and on the next strategy funding cycle your investment will be live!

Get Started

Conclusions and Recommendations

The evolving role of alternative investments in pension plans reflects a broader industry transformation aimed at enhancing funding status, reducing volatility, and generating superior risk-adjusted returns. This evolution—from niche to core—necessitates a holistic approach that integrates:

For pension sponsors and asset managers, the imperative is clear: modernize operations, embrace alternative asset strategies with a balanced view of returns versus complexity, and navigate a rapidly changing regulatory landscape with agility and prudence.

Recommendations:

  • For DB Plans: Prioritize liability-hedging investments and integrate alternatives gradually via tailored LDI and glide path strategies.
  • For DC Plans: Leverage pooled investment vehicles and innovative product structures (e.g., target date funds with embedded alternatives) to provide enhanced diversification and returns.
  • For Regulators and Policy Makers: Continue to refine fiduciary standards and safe harbor guidelines, ensuring that expanded access to alternative assets is balanced with robust investor protection measures.

By adopting these strategic practices, pension plans can better meet long-term obligations and adapt to a rapidly evolving market environment, setting a new standard for retirement investment excellence.

This final report captures the complete spectrum of learnings from extensive research, providing a comprehensive roadmap for incorporating alternative assets into pension portfolios. The integration of multi-dimensional data—from market trends, regulatory shifts, and technological advances—ensures that the strategies recommended herein are both actionable and sustainable, positioning pension funds for long-term success in an increasingly complex investment landscape.

Sources

Ready to Invest in Alternatives?

Get Started

Was this information useful?
(21ratings, Ø 5.0)
« Dynamic Regimes: Enhancing Alternative Investments Through Adaptive Allocation
Dynamic Vintage Risk Management: Integrating Opportunistic Strategies for Alpha Generation »